Sometimes love deserves a second chance.
These Christian second-chance romance books are filled with former sweethearts, missed opportunities, and couples finding their way back to each other. If you love faith-filled romances about love getting another chance, these books are worth adding to your reading list.
Affiliate Disclaimer: This post contains Amazon affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting Fictional Retreats!
Christian Second-Chance Romance Books
Some of these books are included with a Kindle+ subscription. If you’re new to Kindle+, you can start a free 30-day trial here.
Second Chance With the Hero — Liwen Y. Ho
Josephine Gilbert never expected to need help from the ex-husband who left her twenty years ago. But after an unexpected surgery, Jack returns to care for her. He’s hoping to make things right, though Josephine isn’t sure she can trust him again.
Second Chance Ranch — Liz Isaacson
Squire Ackerman is back in Three Rivers after an injury ends his military career. Kelly Armstrong has returned after a difficult divorce and needs a fresh start for herself and her child.
Taking a job at Squire’s family ranch brings her face-to-face with the man whose prom invitation she never answered.
The One That Got Away — Tara Grace Ericson
Fire captain Storm is tired of his mom’s friends trying to find him a wife. When his high school best friend, Krystal, returns to town to organize a charity auction, he sees an opportunity to get them off his back. All they have to do is let everyone believe there’s more to their friendship.
To Bring You Back — Emily Conrad
Nearly a decade after their relationship ended, rock star Gannon Vaughn returns to Lakeshore, Wisconsin, hoping to win back Adeline Green.
She’s found some peace in her small-town life, but reconnecting with Gannon could bring up painful memories and unwanted attention from reporters.
So You Want a Second Chance — Elizabeth Maddrey
After a heart attack, billionaire Joe Robinson finds himself under the care of Cynthia Mitchell, the woman he hasn’t forgotten in thirty years.
She’s built a successful career as a surgeon, but letting Joe back into her life means risking her heart all over again.
A Second Chance in Blue Ridge Bay — Cara Joy
Destiny Rogers has spent twelve years trying to forget her feelings for Brandon Matthews, the childhood best friend who left town and ignored her.
When he unexpectedly returns to Blue Ridge Bay for the summer, he’s determined to win her heart. Destiny, however, has no intention of making it easy for him.
If you love Christian romance, I’ve got even more books to share! Take a look at my Christian Romance Books post for more recommendations.
Stay With Me — Rose Fresquez
After twelve years apart, Ruby runs into her high school sweetheart, Ethan Bishop. He’s now a widowed pastor raising his children in Meadowbrook.
As they reconnect, Ruby worries about facing the same problems that ended their relationship years ago.
Destiny — Chas Williamson
Selena Harper returns home after ending her career as an Army nurse, hoping to figure out what’s next. When she runs into her former love, Trey Brubaker, she discovers he’s dating another woman. But Trey hasn’t forgotten Selena, even after all these years.
With Every Breath — Natasha D Frazier
With only thirty days to live, Nina Robinson reaches out to her former college sweetheart, Andrew McCall, and asks him to join her in the Bahamas.
He’s close to reaching an important career goal, but after learning about Nina’s illness, he agrees to go. Their reunion gives them another chance at the relationship they once shared.
A Cowboy’s Second Chance — Tara Baisden
Conner Hart has spent the last ten years on the rodeo circuit, leaving his family ranch and Rachel Nolan behind. When his father’s passing brings him back to Montana, he’s determined to make things right. But Rachel has built a life of her own and isn’t sure she wants to risk getting hurt again.
Dearly Loved — Bonnie Blythe
Meredith Ambrose has built a quiet life as a nurse, leaving behind the heartbreak of her teenage years. When David Steller, the man she once loved, ends up in her hospital unit, she discovers he came to town looking for her. Now David hopes to win her heart, but Meredith hasn’t forgotten the past.
The Rancher’s Heart — Carolyne Aarsen
Anara never planned to return to Kittering Creek, but the chance to run her family’s bakery brings her home. Her return puts her back in Morgan Properzi’s life, years after tragedy and betrayal tore them apart. Now they have to face the past they’ve both tried to move on from.
If you like romance with a little mystery and suspense, take a look at my Christian Romantic Suspense Books list for more reading ideas.
Summer’s Salvation — Dora Hiers
Harper Robyson left her boyfriend, Denton Parker, five years ago to help her twin sister after a devastating attack. Now she’s raising her niece and returning to Laurel Cove for a new job. Denton still loves Harper, but seeing her with a little girl leaves him questioning what really happened when she left.
Second Chance Romance — Jill Weatherholt
Single dad Jackson Daughtry is focused on raising his daughter and helping run a local café. When lawyer Melanie Harper arrives in town, they get off to a rocky start. But after they begin working together, Jackson discovers there’s more to Melanie than he first thought.
Second Chance Love — Kelsey MacBride
Tracy Moore never forgot the day she left her fiancé, Paul, at the altar. Now they’re attending a wedding together on a tropical island, where old feelings begin to resurface. But when a car accident leaves them stranded and injured, Paul must find help before it’s too late.
Second Chance in Summit County — Katherine Karrol
A woman looking for a fresh start settles in a small Michigan town after her life falls apart. She meets a single dad who’s devoted to his daughter and has sworn off love. Neither plans on falling for someone new, but their feelings soon begin to change.
Want to come back to this list? Save it on Pinterest!
I hope these Christian second-chance romance books gave you a few new titles to add to your reading list!
Have you read any of these books? Or is there one I missed that you’d recommend? Let me know in the comments!
Leave a Reply